Darren Criss and Chris Colfer Reunite at Royal Albert Hall for First Glee Duet in Over a Decade

Darren Criss made his Royal Albert Hall debut on Sunday, Oct. 18 with two back-to-back shows, and he used the moment to bring a beloved Glee duo back together. Midway through“Baby, It’s Cold Outside,”the song he originally performed with Chris Colfer on the show, Criss told the crowd he was going to sing both parts. Then Colfer walked out, marking the pair’s first joint performance since Glee ended in 2015.

The surprises kept coming. Alan Cumming joined for ABBA’s“Does Your Mother Know,”Gaten Matarazzo performed“Lost Boys Life,”and Sarah Hyland sang“Suddenly Seymour,”with Jesse Tyler Ferguson also appearing across the two shows. Criss closed the night alongside a local youth choir, performing“Somewhere Only We Know”and“Teenage Dream.”

For fans of Kurt and Blaine, the reunion was a decade-overdue payoff, a reminder that Glee’s fan base never really went anywhere. Which Glee performance would you most want to see reunited on stage? Tell us in the comments.