Convicted and Fighting Back: Karmelo Anthony Appeals 35-Year Murder Sentence

The legal battle isn’t over for Karmelo Anthony—not by a long shot. Less than 24 hours after a Texas jury handed down a guilty verdict and a 35-year prison sentence for the fatal stabbing of Austin Metcalf at a Frisco track meet, Anthony’s legal team filed a notice of appeal, signaling they’re far from ready to accept the outcome.

According to court records obtained by TMZ, attorney Mike Howard issued a statement on behalf of Anthony, arguing that the appellate courts need to examine several important issues from the trial. Howard noted that an appeal is a fundamental right afforded to every American, regardless of the circumstances. The move comes after jurors rejected Anthony’s self-defense claim during what was described as emotionally charged testimony and closing arguments.

What makes this case particularly striking is the wall of support that continues to surround Anthony despite the conviction. His GiveSendGo fundraising page has swelled to well over $629,000, with donations still pouring in. Even Cardi B weighed in on social media following the verdict, adding another layer of public attention to what’s already been a nationally watched case since Anthony’s arrest in April 2025.

The contrast between the conviction and the public support tells a complicated story. While the Metcalf family reportedly expressed satisfaction with the 35-year sentence—sources connected to the case told TMZ they’re very happy with the verdict—the continued financial backing of Anthony’s defense efforts suggests there’s a significant segment of the public who either believe the conviction was unjust or are sympathetic to his broader circumstances. Meanwhile, Anthony is currently being held in isolation at Collin County Jail while officials determine his long-term placement.

The appellate process will now test whether the trial itself was conducted properly or whether grounds exist for a new trial. It’s a lengthy road ahead, but for Anthony and his supporters, it’s one they’re apparently prepared to travel.