Brianna Chickenfry Calls Foul on Amanda and West's Story

When a relationship timeline doesn’t add up, sometimes the people closest to the drama are the first to smell it.

Brianna“Chickenfry”LaPaglia isn’t buying what Amanda Batula and West Wilson are selling. During the Sunday, May 31 episode of her Plan Bri podcast, the 26-year-old podcast host made it clear she has serious doubts about when Amanda and West actually got intimate. According to their official story, they waited until after they went public with their relationship in a joint statement on March 31 to sleep together. But Brianna has a different recollection.

Here’s where it gets interesting: back at the 2026 Super Bowl on February 8, West allegedly told Brianna that he and Amanda were“a thing.”If that’s true, it means they were already entangled weeks before their carefully worded announcement ever hit the internet. During part one of the Summer House season 10 reunion on May 26, Amanda and West claimed their first kiss happened in late February—but Brianna’s Super Bowl intel suggests the relationship was already established by then. She didn’t call out specific details about when they slept together, but her message was crystal clear: something doesn’t line up.

What makes this messier is the context. Amanda had been married to Kyle Cooke before announcing their separation just three months before she and West went public. West was friends with Ciara Miller, who had previously dated him and was open about how much their 2023 breakup hurt her—and Ciara was Amanda’s best friend. It’s a tangled web, and Brianna seems to think the timeline they’ve presented is a way to clean it up retroactively.

To her credit, Brianna was transparent about her skepticism from the start. She told West and Amanda during a night out that she planned to address the drama on her podcast. She’s been honest about the fact that West and Amanda have been kind to her personally, even though she doesn’t agree with what happened. But honesty also meant calling out what she sees as an inconsistency. Brianna hasn’t spoken to them since—a choice she described as fair.

The real question isn’t necessarily whether they hooked up on day X versus day Y. It’s whether the narrative they’ve built holds water. And right now, at least one person who was there is saying it doesn’t.