The saga that started in a GMA3 scandal has officially produced two lasting couples. Andrew Shue confirmed to People on Wednesday that he’s engaged to Marilee Fiebig, revealing they got engaged in the spring after three years of dating. Their relationship began in 2023, shortly after their exes, Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes, went public with their own romance amid a very messy, very public scandal that ended both of their GMA3 careers in January 2023.
The timing of it all is what makes this story so wild. Robach and Holmes married in a private Arkansas ceremony on Sept. 19, a day after applying for their marriage license. Meanwhile, Shue and Fiebig quietly kept their engagement under wraps for months. Shue has been open about the personal growth that came out of the divorce era, telling People that there’s a happy ending in all of this and that the magic of love is going from a need to giving.
So where does that leave the scoreboard? Four people, two couples, zero storyline loose ends. Shue and Fiebig kept things private and peaceful, while Robach and Holmes went public and got married in Arkansas. Different playbooks, same result.
Which couple do you think handled their fresh start better: the quiet engagement or the private wedding?
About the Author
Local Lawton
Local Lawton is a contributor to LocalBeat, covering local news and community stories.