Statistical Shenanigans: Are 70% of Deported Immigrants Really Criminals?

The notion that 70% of immigrants deported from U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) custody have criminal convictions or pending charges has been put to the statistical test—and the results are eye-opening. According to a recent analysis by the Cato Institute, only 57% of those deported had any criminal connection, and a staggering 70% had no convictions at all. So, what gives?

In November 2025, nearly half of this deported demographic had only pending charges, which leaves us with a more complex picture of who exactly is being deported. Out of the 222,401 individuals released from ICE in 2025, 40% had criminal convictions while 22% had outstanding charges—again muddying the narrative that many have believed.

With only 1.64% of new deportation cases in FY 2026 rooted in alleged criminal activity (excluding illegal entry), it’s clear that simplifying the issue into catchy stats can lead to misconceptions. It prompts us to question not just the data, but also how it is presented to the public. Just when you think you’ve got a solid understanding of immigration enforcement, the numbers turn around and wave goodbye. Isn’t it amazing how statistics can turn a heated debate on its head?