When you’re posting about criminal justice reform on one of the world’s biggest platforms, mistakes can get expensive—especially when you accidentally tag the wrong person.
Kim Kardashian, 45, just secured her second courtroom victory in a case that started with what should’ve been a simple error. Back in February 2024, the Skims founder posted a series of Instagram stories promoting a death row case. She meant to highlight Ivan Cantu, a Texas man convicted of murder and awaiting execution. Problem: she used a photo of Ivan Cantu, a completely different guy—a project manager based in New York who shared the exact same name. The image went up two days before the Texas prisoner’s execution on February 28, 2024, and stayed live for hours before her team caught it and took it down.
The New York-based Cantu sued in February 2025, claiming the misidentification caused him emotional distress, sleep loss, and post-traumatic stress disorder. His demand? $186,000 in damages. A judge dismissed the case entirely in November 2025, siding with Kardashian’s argument that it was a genuine mistake corrected quickly and accompanied by an apology. When she filed for legal fees in response, Cantu pushed back hard, arguing he’d face financial ruin and that Kardashian—sitting on a net worth over $1 billion—hardly needed the money. The judge wasn’t moved.
On May 11, the court awarded Kardashian $167,000 of the $186,000 she’d requested to cover her legal expenses. Her attorney, Michael Rhodes, had framed the whole thing clearly:“It was a simple mistake of using the public photo of another man with the same name to promote Kim’s longstanding commitment to the cause of criminal justice reform.”The image was gone almost immediately once discovered.
What this really highlights is the messy intersection of social media’s speed, celebrity activism, and the cost of getting things wrong in public. Kardashian’s been vocal about criminal justice reform for years, but one mix-up with a name spiraled into months of litigation and six figures in legal bills. It’s a reminder that even when you’re trying to do something good, the machinery of the internet—and the courts—can turn a simple mistake into something far bigger.
About the Author
Local Lawton
Local Lawton is a contributor to LocalBeat, covering local news and community stories.