A routine medical scan became life-altering for Joe Amabile when doctors discovered something no one sees coming: a blueberry-sized lesion in his brain. The 40-year-old Bachelor in Paradise star went public on Monday, July 13, with the sobering news that what appeared to be an early-stage glioma—a type of brain tumor—would require immediate surgical intervention at Memorial Sloan Kettering.
Amabile’s revelation came through an Instagram video where he described the whirlwind of the past few weeks with surprising candor. He’d initially kept his Prenuvo scan results private, but when doctors flagged the lesion, a follow-up brain MRI confirmed his worst fears. Now, with surgery scheduled for two weeks out, he’s facing a craniotomy—actual brain surgery—to have the growth removed and tested. His tone throughout was measured but honest: this wasn’t something he ever thought would happen to him, yet here he is.
What makes Amabile’s decision to share this so significant is the vulnerability it required. He admitted to wrestling with whether to post about it at all, ultimately deciding that since this is now part of his life, keeping silent felt wrong. That openness resonated immediately. His former Dancing With the Stars partner Jenna Johnson, Bachelorette’s Zac Clark, and fellow Bachelor Nation alum Jason Tartick all flooded the comments with messages of support and love. In a franchise known for manufactured drama and curated narratives, this felt genuinely human.
For those following along with Bachelor Nation’s timeline, Amabile’s journey has been anything but ordinary. He showed up as a contestant on Becca Kufrin’s season 14 of The Bachelorette in 2018, then pivoted to Bachelor in Paradise season 5 where he met Kendall Long. After that relationship ended in 2020, he returned to BiP in season 7 and found his person in Serena Pitt—they married in October 2022. Now, just as his life seemed settled, he’s confronting something that puts romance and reality TV drama in stark perspective.
The silver lining, if there is one, rests in his early detection and medical team’s assessment that this is truly early-stage. Amabile’s determination to stay positive while leaning on his support system—family, friends, and apparently, the tight-knit Bachelor community—gives him real momentum heading into the weeks ahead. Surgery is imminent, recovery will be challenging, and the testing that follows will determine the next steps. But for now, his willingness to let people in during one of life’s hardest moments is its own kind of strength.
About the Author
Local Lawton
Local Lawton is a contributor to LocalBeat, covering local news and community stories.