Craig Conover Sold Paige DeSorbo's Engagement Ring and Bought a Rental Property

Craig Conover says the diamond he bought for Paige DeSorbo is gone. On the“Two Ts in a Pod”podcast, the Southern Charm star explained that he returned the ring to his jeweler, who recently sold it to a buyer. The payout was enough to buy a rental property, though he admitted demand for that particular cut has dropped. One chapter of the breakup just became a real estate portfolio.

There’s just one complication, and it’s a big one. DeSorbo has publicly claimed the ring never existed at all. During the Summer House season 9 reunion, she argued that no one would let him return a custom ring a year later. Conover’s version comes with a jeweler and a sale. Hers comes with pure disbelief. The couple dated for three years before DeSorbo announced the split in December 2024.

Since then, DeSorbo has moved on with Joe D’Amelio. Conover says he’s single, dating with intent, and on Raya, though he hasn’t actually gone on a date from the app yet. So the man with the rental property and the mystery ring is still waiting on his first match to turn into plans.

Do you believe the ring existed? Sound off in the comments.